Thursday, July 29, 2021

US electronic mail hacker will get his “pc trespass” conviction reversed – Bare Safety

This week’s fascinating Friday fable reaches back nearly a decade, and is a reminder of how hard it can be to decide what wrong has been done, if any, in court cases that deal with what most people would call “hacking”.

The story of the original court case is simply told, and it goes like this.

In late 2013, X was brought in as an IT manager for a city in the state of Georgia in the US, supposedly to “increase the reliability and efficiency of the City’s computer system.”

X seems to have decided that Y’s work wasn’t up to scratch, and “criticized Y’s work performance, which led to an argument and a loud outburst from Y.”

The outcome of this, it seems, is that Y had some of his IT powers reduced for security reasons, and sadly ended up getting fired in mid-2014.

A couple of months after Y’s departure, X received an email from another colleague, whom we shall call Z, and replied as he normally would…

…only to receive a “bounce” message (a delivery failure) from a mysterious external email address, Q.